Test business fit
Practice priorities, market, capacity and exclusions.
Ask a prospective law-firm SEO company to show what it would change on one of your practice pages. The explanation should connect the searcher's question to the matters you handle, the attorney who reviews the content and the intake team that will receive the request.

Law-firm SEO partner scorecard
A useful evaluation connects the firm’s commercial fit with technical execution, expert review, asset ownership and intake evidence.
Practice priorities, market, capacity and exclusions.
Technical, content, local and authority decisions.
Review, access, ownership and reporting responsibilities.
Qualified intake, opportunities and clearly bounded proof.
That conversation gives you a starting point for comparing proposals. Use the guide below to check the work, ownership and reporting before deciding how much ongoing support the firm needs.
Write down the practice area, side of representation and jurisdiction. Include the matters the firm is equipped to accept, current capacity and broad reasons intake declines requests. Keep confidential details out of the marketing brief.
Be specific. A firm receiving inquiries from the wrong state needs a different first task from a firm whose service page is missing from search, and the proposal should explain that distinction before promising more traffic.
Ask for a sample finding. The agency should identify the page or technical behaviour, show its evidence and explain the proposed correction, with the firm's own priorities determining which work happens first.
Google's hiring guidance recommends asking about previous work, expected results, communication and the reasons behind recommendations. It also cautions against first-place guarantees and recommends read-only Search Console access at the audit stage. Use those questions when comparing providers.
Name the reviewing attorney. Agree how the agency will gather source material, prepare drafts and record approval before the firm commits to a publishing schedule. Reviewer time belongs in the scope.
For California firms, the State Bar's Chapter 7 rules address communications about legal services, including misleading claims and the context around results or testimonials. Your firm should apply its own professional review and the rules of every jurisdiction it serves.
Compare the plan with your actual offices and service area. Ask how the agency will handle listings, attorney information and practice pages, then inspect a proposed city page before approving a large set of them.
Google's Business Profile guidelines require accurate business representation and distinguish eligible locations from arrangements such as virtual offices. Have the agency explain the applicable requirements for each profile. A service-area page does not by itself establish a staffed office.
Read a case study with its limits attached. Look for the starting point, work delivered, source and reporting period, and ask which conclusions the underlying records support. A search gain alone cannot establish retained matters.
Outreach needs an owner. Agree who approves messages and client references, which placements involve payment and what evidence would show a legitimate editorial mention. The agency should be able to discuss that work without guaranteeing coverage.
Confirm account access before signing. The proposal should explain domain ownership, website source, content rights and access to analytics, listings and advertising accounts, including what can be exported if the relationship ends.
Agree broad intake stages with the firm. Keep accepted inquiries, consultations and retained matters separate, and record unknown outcomes rather than counting them as wins. Ask how source context reaches the intake system without sending confidential matter details into marketing tools.
The opening plan should identify the evidence to collect and the first journey to improve. A practice-page correction, an approved attorney profile and a working contact route may be an appropriate starting scope, with later work depending on what the firm learns.
Put the review in the calendar. The agency and intake owner should leave that meeting with a decision about the next priority, using the work completed and the inquiry context available. Ninety days is a planning horizon, not a ranking deadline.
| Decision | Evidence to request | Question for the firm |
|---|---|---|
| Practice fit | A proposed page priority linked to the actual matter brief | Does the plan reflect our jurisdiction, representation and intake capacity? |
| Technical work | A reproduced issue, proposed correction and verification | Who implements changes and can explain the result? |
| Content review | A sample brief, sources and attorney-approval process | Can our reviewer support the workload? |
| Scope and cost | Defined deliverables, fees and separately identified media or third-party costs | What is included, and what would change the fee? |
| Ownership and exit | Written account access, rights, exports and handoff terms | Which assets are owned or licensed, and what happens at the end? |
| Measurement | Source, period and broad intake-stage definitions | How will unknown or unsuitable requests appear in reporting? |
Use the scorecard in a working session. Ask each provider to explain one actual recommendation and the evidence behind it, then record any unanswered question before comparing the fees. This is a selection tool, not a ranking of agencies.
Ask for a scoped plan. It should establish the starting evidence, identify priority pages and measurement gaps, assign implementation and attorney review, then set a checkpoint for the next decision. The sequence depends on the firm. It is not a promise of rankings or inquiries within 90 days.
Get the arrangement in writing. Confirm domain registration, website source, content rights and access to search, analytics and advertising accounts. Separate ownership from third-party licenses, and agree what can be exported or transferred when the engagement ends.
Read the source and period. The Howley case reports a defined employment-law search-recovery comparison, while Peck Law covers a different practice and local-search window. Their search results do not quantify retained matters. Ask which parts of a proposed plan apply to your firm.
Define the delivery gap. If the firm needs practice content, website work and intake reporting coordinated alongside search, compare a connected scope with the people available internally. Growth Friday's law-firm marketing page explains that ongoing model, while the content guide describes attorney input.
Get a free Search & AI Visibility Snapshot for your law firm, reviewed by a Growth Friday specialist. Tell us the practice area and market you want to reach. We'll check relevant Google searches and AI buyer questions, then identify gaps in how prospective clients find and evaluate your firm.
Delivered within 24 hours. No meeting required.
Follow the relevant services and reading for law-firm growth.